The Worst Cities for Starting a New SEO Agency

#
  • seo
  • November 17, 2025

The Worst Cities for Starting a New SEO Agency

Starting a new SEO agency requires careful consideration of the location, as certain cities pose more significant challenges than others. Factors like market saturation, demand for SEO services, operational costs, and local talent availability play a major role in the success of an agency. In this article, we’ll explore the worst cities for aspiring SEO agency owners and why they might hinder business growth.

Cities with High Competition

San Francisco, California
San Francisco is a city known for its booming tech industry, and as a result, the market for SEO services is highly competitive. Established SEO firms and digital agencies dominate the city, leaving little room for new entrants. The sheer volume of established agencies means that breaking into the market requires substantial effort, extensive resources, and strong differentiators.
New York City, New York
New York City, often referred to as the business hub of the world, is home to a dense concentration of digital marketing agencies. While the city offers vast opportunities, its saturated market means newcomers face fierce competition. Digital marketing agencies in NYC specialize in a variety of services, including SEO, which makes standing out and gaining traction a difficult task for new agencies.

Cities with Low Demand for SEO Services

Bakersfield, California
Bakersfield is a smaller city with a limited business community, resulting in a lower demand for SEO services. While there are always businesses that could benefit from SEO, the population of companies in need of digital marketing is far less compared to larger cities. This lack of demand means that starting an SEO agency here may result in difficulties in acquiring clients and establishing a profitable business.
Toledo, Ohio
Toledo has a more traditional economy that is less focused on digital marketing, which makes it a tough market for an SEO agency. Many businesses in Toledo still rely on traditional forms of marketing and may not fully understand the importance of SEO. This leads to fewer businesses actively seeking SEO expertise, limiting the potential client base for a new agency.

Cities with High Operational Costs

Los Angeles, California
Los Angeles is known for its high operational costs, including rent, salaries, and business expenses. Starting an SEO agency in LA requires substantial capital investment to cover overheads. The high cost of living in the city translates into higher wages for employees and office space costs, which can limit profitability for new agencies.

Washington, D.C.
Washington, D.C. also suffers from high operational costs, including expensive office spaces and high wages. While there may be demand for SEO services in the area, the cost of running a business in D.C. can take a heavy toll on a new agency’s finances. These costs, combined with competitive market conditions, can reduce profitability, especially in the early stages of business.

Cities with Limited Access to Talent

Omaha, Nebraska
Omaha’s smaller market size means that finding skilled digital marketing professionals, especially those specializing in SEO, can be a challenge. With fewer educational institutions offering specialized digital marketing programs, Omaha’s talent pool is smaller than in other tech-centric cities. This makes it harder for new SEO agencies to recruit skilled staff or collaborate with experienced professionals.
Little Rock, Arkansas
Little Rock faces similar challenges to Omaha when it comes to accessing skilled SEO professionals. While there are opportunities in digital marketing, the local talent pool may not be as robust, making it more difficult for new agencies to find experienced SEO experts. In addition, the demand for digital marketing services in the area may not be high enough to support multiple agencies.

Cities with Economic Instability

Detroit, Michigan
Detroit’s economy has been in a state of flux for several years. While the city has experienced a resurgence, it still faces economic challenges that could affect local businesses’ ability to invest in SEO services. Economic instability often leads to budget cuts, and businesses may prioritize other expenses over marketing services. For new SEO agencies, this can result in slow business growth and lower client acquisition rates.
Flint, Michigan
Flint, Michigan, also grapples with economic challenges, which can impact the demand for SEO services. As businesses in the area face financial struggles, investing in SEO may not be a priority. This lack of investment in digital marketing services can be a significant obstacle for new agencies trying to establish themselves.

Cities with Regulatory Challenges

San Francisco, California
San Francisco has some of the strictest business regulations in the country, which can make it challenging for new agencies to operate smoothly. Strict rules on employment, zoning, and other aspects of business regulation can increase operational complexity. New SEO agencies must be prepared for additional administrative work and potential compliance challenges.
New York City, New York
New York City is notorious for its complex regulatory environment. Navigating through city ordinances, business licenses, and taxes can be a significant hurdle for startups. The administrative burden associated with regulatory compliance can divert time and resources away from growing the business.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes. San Francisco’s saturated market, with numerous established agencies, makes it difficult for new SEO agencies to stand out and thrive.

Yes. While some small cities may have limited demand for SEO services, others may present opportunities by focusing on specific niches or industries that require digital marketing expertise.

Yes. High operational costs in cities like San Francisco and Los Angeles can significantly reduce the profitability of new SEO agencies.

When choosing a city, consider factors such as market demand for SEO services, competition levels, operational costs, access to skilled talent, and economic stability. Each factor plays a crucial role in determining the long-term success of your agency.

Yes. SEO agencies can still thrive in cities with a smaller talent pool by focusing on remote hiring or outsourcing, allowing them to tap into global talent. However, having local professionals can provide a competitive edge.

Economic instability, as seen in cities like Detroit and Flint, can reduce local businesses’ marketing budgets, leading to fewer opportunities for SEO agencies. Agencies in economically stable areas are likely to experience more consistent growth.

No. The high level of competition in NYC, along with the dense concentration of marketing agencies, makes it harder for new SEO agencies to gain a foothold in the market.

Yes. Cities with fewer regulatory hurdles allow SEO agencies to operate more smoothly, saving time and resources that can be better spent on growing the business.

Yes. Cities with a growing tech scene, like Austin, offer more opportunities for SEO agencies, especially with tech companies needing SEO expertise to improve their online visibility.

Yes. Despite high competition, San Francisco’s tech-focused ecosystem provides ample networking opportunities that can benefit new SEO agencies looking to grow their client base and expand their knowledge.

City We Serve